Dash it all – why the change?

When I was growing up – a long time back – we were taught some pretty simple rules regarding punctuation.  This was ‘back in the day’ when we used a pencil or pen and paper, or – if something had to be very formal – a typewriter.

Most typewriters being mechanical devices which limited the number of functions per key – compared with computer keyboards and some electric typewriters – had a hyphen or dash or minus, a common key for all three functions.

Using these was not rocket science.  A minus sign was pretty obvious, that is if it was surrounded by numbers in an equation, you could be pretty sure it was a minus, and if otherwise surrounded by numbers it would be a dash and indicate a range thereof.  Context was the key.

eg. 3 – 2 = 1
or June 6 – 9

A hyphen (or an hyphen…) was used in the still common usage, to separate a prefix or suffix, or to break a long word up for readability, or to put some of it on a new line, or several other uses (yes I am also a fan of the Oxford comma, but that’s another story).  Quite simply, a hyphen had no spaces around it.  It was space-less.

eg. re-entry
or hyphen-

A dash was a hyphen with a space either side, used to separate out an interruption to a sentance, similar to a comma or parentheses.

eg. Jack and Jill – an unmarried couple – went up the hill.

Now that the world of the internet is so US-centric, the humble dash has not only been complicated, but used in a way which – to my way of thinking – spoils the use of it completely.  We now have frequent use of the ‘endash’ and the ’emdash’ and the original dash – a hyphen with a space either side – has almost disappeared.

An endash (–) is a dash about the width of a letter n and an emdash (—) is about the width of a letter m and both are used in the place where a dash – a hyphen with a space either side – would have been used.

The endash is used in dates and numbers etc, whilst the emdash is used in sentences. So June 6 – 9 becomes June 6–9 and my Jack and Jill example above would now look like:

eg. Jack and Jill—an unmarried couple—went up the hill.

How messy.  And it gets worse when there’s several of them in the same paragraph.  To my eye – and mind – the dash with spaces looks neat, is obvious and cannot be mistaken for a hyphenated word.  The American usage—the way which cheeses me off—is – in my mind’s eye – far messier, ungainly and just plain wrong.

So while I’m writing for a predominately US audience – as I frequently do on a couple of other sites – I’ll use the endash and emdash but here on my Aussie site, I’m gonna stick with the poms (British). It was, after all, their language to begin with dash it all.

This entry was posted in Cheese 2012. Bookmark the permalink.